Choosing a garment is not a mere act of vanity or the simple pursuit of shape and fit. It is a decision that speaks of comfort, purpose, and perhaps even the soul of a person. The fabric used in that garment—whether wool, cotton, or some blend of earth and human ingenuity—shapes more than just its form. It determines its warmth, its cost, and whether it walks more lightly on this planet.

Picture yourself on a summer day, wandering down the avenue. The sun beats down, and you notice the crowd swathed mostly in cotton—nature’s own offering, soft and cool against the heat, a fabric as familiar as the fields from which it sprang. Cotton, the most popular of all naturally-sourced fibers, wraps itself around the world in easy comfort.

But come winter, the scene shifts. The same streets are now adorned with wool—thick, warm, protective. Wool comes from the sheep, from the earth, carrying with it the story of survival, of warmth amid cold winds. You see people bundled in wool’s embrace, standing firm against the season’s chill, wrapped in nature’s best answer to winter’s bite.

Today, we’ll explore the tales of wool and cotton—their strengths, their differences, and the reasons why one might be chosen over the other. And perhaps, by knowing their stories, you’ll make better decisions for yourself, whether it’s socks to warm your feet or a jacket to shield your shoulders from the changing skies.

Are cotton and wool the same?

Today, we’ll explore the tales of wool and cotton—their strengths, their differences, and the reasons why one might be chosen over the other. And perhaps, by knowing their stories, you’ll make better decisions for yourself, whether it’s socks to warm your feet or a jacket to shield your shoulders from the changing skies.

No, when comparing wool and cotton—two of the most popular natural fibers used in clothing today—you immediately see two key differences:

• Cotton is light; wool is thicker.
• Cotton feels cool; wool feels warm and soft.

Beyond that, perhaps the most significant difference lies in their origins. Cotton comes from the fields, the humble cotton plant, grown under the watchful sun. Wool, on the other hand, comes from animals, the sheep that roam the pastures, growing their coats as nature's answer to the cold.

When processed into textiles and clothing, cotton is often a more economical choice for manufacturers. It lends itself well to garment making because it is:

• Resistant to abrasion
• Dyeable
• Washable and ironable at high temperatures
• Comfortable to wear

Wool, however, is a luxury, a rarer find compared to the abundance of cotton. Its scarcity elevates it, and manufacturers value it for garment making because it is:

• Extremely durable and resistant to tearing
• Naturally wrinkle-resistant
• Dyeable
• Colorfast

Each fiber tells its own story—one of lightness and ease, the other of warmth and resilience. Understanding these qualities helps us choose the garment that will serve us best, that will carry us through the seasons in comfort and style.

MIA MELON LEXI PERFORMANCE WOOL COAT

How are cotton and wool harvested?

Cotton plants are among the most plentiful crops globally, likely because they are economically produced. Cotton comes from the fluffy part around the seeds of the cotton plant—fluff designed by nature to help the seeds travel long distances on the wind, finding new places to grow.

To harvest cotton, these puffs and their attached seeds are gathered, usually by machine. Farmers have several harvesting methods, but most involve specially designed farm equipment to ease the process. Once harvested, the cotton undergoes a cleaning process to remove seeds and debris. Then, it is spun into bales and sent to textile mills for processing, where it will eventually be transformed into fabric, ready to be made into clothing.

Wool is harvested from the soft fleece on a sheep and is typically done in the spring when the animals no longer need their natural winter coat. The process of harvesting and processing wool includes six main steps:

1. Shearing: The wool is carefully shorn from the sheep using electric clippers, much like giving the animal a haircut. This is typically done in a single piece, called a fleece.
2. Sorting and Grading: The fleece is sorted and graded based on the quality and length of the fibers. Different parts of the fleece have different qualities, which will determine their use.
3. Scouring: The wool is washed thoroughly to remove dirt, grease, and other impurities. This washing process, called scouring, ensures the wool is clean and ready for further processing.
4. Carding: The clean wool is then carded, which means it is brushed and straightened to separate the fibers and align them. This process produces a continuous web of fibers, which can be spun into yarn.
5. Spinning: The carded wool is spun into yarn. This step twists the fibers together, creating a strong, continuous thread that can be woven or knitted into fabric.
6. Finishing: Finally, the wool yarn or fabric is finished, which might include dyeing, treating for softness, or adding other characteristics to prepare it for garment production.

MIA MELON STELLA WATERPROOF COTTON HERRINGBONE JACKET

Cotton vs Wool: Which Reigns Supreme?

When you're standing in a store aisle, a jacket in each hand, one made of cotton, the other of wool, you might wonder: which material is truly better? Let’s take a stroll through the fields of cotton and the sheep-studded hills to see where each shines, and where it might stumble.

Which is Warmer?

Wool wins this round and hardly breaks a sweat while doing so. It’s a natural insulator, the kind of fiber you’d want around your shoulders on a windy, winter night, huddled close to a campfire. Cotton, on the other hand, prefers warmer days—it's the sun-soaked afternoon at a picnic, not the stormy night in the hills. Cotton's light touch makes it perfect for summer days when warmth is the enemy and coolness your goal.

Which is More Durable?

If it's a contest of raw strength, cotton fibers stand their ground well. But durability is about more than simple might—it's about resilience, the ability to bend, sway, and adapt without snapping. Wool, with its flexibility, dances gracefully in the wind, bending 20,000 times before br

eaking, while cotton, though strong, finds itself more brittle by comparison. Wool bends; cotton holds fast—both endure, but in their own way.

Which is More Eco-Friendly?

In a world longing for greener choices, cotton and wool both have their virtues. Both come from the earth—cotton from fields that sway in summer breezes, wool sheared from sheep wandering green pastures. They biodegrade, they renew. Yet, nothing is simple. Cotton drinks deeply from the well, guzzling water, and calls for the aid of pesticides, while wool production, despite its simpler look, belches greenhouse gases into the sky. When it comes to eco-friendliness, it’s less about choosing the hero and more about choosing the lesser impact.

MIA MELON EVERGLADES WATERPROOF COTTON HERRINGBONE JACKET

Which is More Breathable?

Here, the woolen fiber earns its place in cold-weather gear. Wool breathes deeply in winter air, allowing your body to release warmth without the cold creeping in. It’s a material that knows the value of balance—staying warm without suffocating you. Cotton, though, has its time to shine too. When the summer heat presses down, cotton knows just what to do—it draws sweat away, keeping you cool under the sun’s relentless glare.

Which Performs Better When Soaking Wet?

Picture yourself caught in a sudden downpour—which fabric do you want on your back? Wool might just be the answer. Wool comes coated in lanolin, the sheep’s own natural waterproofing, resisting the rain like a brave herdsman caught in a storm. Even when drenched, wool can hold its own, absorbing up to 30% of its weight in water while keeping you insulated. Cotton, on the other hand, simply soaks it up—and though it maintains its strength, there’s no mistaking the soggy, clinging discomfort of wet cotton against your skin.

MIA MELON HAILEY PERFORMANCE WOOL INSULATED JACKET

So which is better—cotton or wool? The truth is, it’s all about what journey you’re on. Wool for when you face the biting winds and cold adventures, and cotton for when you seek the breeze and lightness of summer days. Both are gifts from nature, each spun with its own strengths and shortcomings, offering warmth or coolness, resilience or simplicity, depending on the path you’re walking.